The Temptations – “I Wish It Would Rain”
Released: December 21, 1967
Album: The Temptations Wish It Would Rain
Written by: Roger Penzabene, Barrett Strong, Norman Whitfield
Produced by: Norman Whitfield
Peak Chart Positions:

• No. 4 on the Billboard Hot 100
• No. 1 on the Billboard R&B Singles Chart

---

About the Song

“I Wish It Would Rain” is a powerful and heartfelt ballad by The Temptations

, fronted by David Ruffin’s evocative and sorrowful lead vocals. The song’s emotional depth was inspired by the real-life heartbreak of lyricist Roger Penzabene, who wrote the lyrics after discovering his wife’s infidelity. Overcome by despair, Penzabene tragically took his own life shortly after the song’s release, adding a haunting authenticity to the lyrics.

---

Musical and Vocal Highlights

The song opens with a solemn piano introduction, setting a mournful tone before Ruffin’s deeply expressive voice takes center stage, accompanied only by a tambourine. This sparse arrangement immediately draws the listener into the raw emotion of the lyrics. As the song progresses, Motown’s Funk Brothers

add understated strings and rhythm, creating a lush yet restrained backdrop for Ruffin’s aching performance.

Ruffin’s delivery is steeped in sorrow, capturing the pain of betrayal and longing for solace. His plea for rain is a metaphor for washing away the tears and the hurt—a request for nature to mirror his inner turmoil. The song’s structure and arrangement bear echoes of Motown’s earlier successes but hint at the evolution to come, with Norman Whitfield’s production style edging closer to the experimental psychedelic soul that would later define the group’s sound.

---

Chart Performance and Legacy

Advertisement

“I Wish It Would Rain” reached No. 1 on the Billboard R&B chart and held that position for several weeks in early 1968. It also peaked at No. 4 on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming one of the group’s most memorable ballads.

This song marked one of Ruffin’s final recordings with The Temptations before his departure in mid-1968. His personal struggles, including a growing cocaine addiction and disputes over leadership within the group, led to his dismissal. Ruffin’s replacement, Dennis Edwards, would usher The Temptations into their next era, defined by the psychedelic soul of songs like “Cloud Nine” and “Ball of Confusion.”

---

Impact and Interpretation

“I Wish It Would Rain” is often regarded as one of the most emotionally resonant songs in The Temptations’ discography. It showcases the group’s ability to tackle themes of heartache and vulnerability, a contrast to the joyful tone of earlier hits like “My Girl.” The song’s poignant lyrics and Ruffin’s unforgettable performance continue to make it a standout track, celebrated for its timeless blend of emotional depth and musical sophistication.

The song’s connection to Penzabene’s personal tragedy only deepens its emotional resonance, making it a stark reminder of the powerful relationship between life, art, and music.